The 3-day training, organised by the SELDI anti-corruption initiative on 12-14 June 2019 in Sarajevo, had as key objectives to inspire CSOs and grassroot organisations to engage in anti-corruption initiatives, instruct them how to apply corruption and state capture monitoring methodologies, and encourage them to collaborate among themselves and with the public institutions in order to achieve positive impact over the national and regional policies.
During the opening, Dr. Janina Berg, Policy Officer at the Center for Thematic Expertise – Rule of Law (Anti-Corruption desk) of DG NEAR, European Commission underlined the importance of CSOs bringing out the voices of the public and holding the institutions accountable. She noted the challenges that countries from the Western Balkans face in the area of the rule of law, and the observed links between organised crime and corruption. In that regard she recommended that countries utilise the principle “fundamentals first” and tackle the issues with greatest negative impact through systematic investigations. Vladimir Pandurevic, Programme Manager for Civil Society/EIDHR/Culture/Youth at the Delegation of the European Union to BiH recommended a stronger cooperation between the public institutions in Bosnia and Herzegovina, necessary in order to tackle state capture.
Day 1 of the training was dedicated to sharing SELDI’s experience and research methods in delivering anti-corruption solutions, advocacy and policy enhancement. SELDI’s experts demonstrated to the CSOs and the grassroots the main SELDI corruption monitoring and anti-corruption assessment instruments, with a specific focus on state capture and corruption risk assessment at institutional level (Monitoring Anticorruption Policy Implementation (MACPI) State Capture, MACPI Micro, Corruption Monitoring System, Hidden Economy Index). The afternoon session was reserved for training the grantees on the specifics of project implementation and reporting based on the EU Rules and Standards. The grantees shared their project ideas, thus finding supporters and collaborators among the audience. The future projects of the grantees will focus on the following topics:
- Democracy Plus, Kosovo* – public procurement monitoring in selected municipalities
- Centar za humanu politiku, BiH – promoting the better treatment of institutional audit reports by the prosecution
- Roma Center for Democracy, Serbia, with project partner the citizen’s organisation for Ecologic and Sustainable Development Green Institute, North Macedonia – assessing the corruption in the spending of public funds for environmental projects
- CSR Communication, Albania – social audit to fight corruption in public procurement
- Studiorum, North Macedonia – conflict of interest as a gateway to corruption
- Centre for Civic Education, Montenegro – misuse of public financing in the higher education
Day 2 of the training focused on two key topics. The first one was the establishment of civil society-media relations and the benefits to CSOs of working with investigative journalists. Day 2 was also dedicated to the final objective of any anti-corruption effort: improving the current policies, strategies and laws through efficient public-private partnerships. All participating anti-corruption agencies from the SEE region and other public organisations tasked with countering corruption confirmed their willingness to work with the civil society. They noted the benefits presented by the human potential of CSOs and grassroots in terms of receiving advice or technical support regarding legislative changes, evaluation of the efficiency of the current policies and strategies and the formulation of new ones. The CSOs and grassroots also gained better understanding on their potential role as partners to the public institutions, and the existing opportunities for policy participation. In addition, all countries highlighted the unsatisfactory rate of reached convictions, despite the numerous instances of corruption uncovered. The anti-corruption agencies explained that their authorities constitute mainly preliminary investigations of corruption cases, education and prevention. Thus, they advocated for stronger commitment by the prosecutors’ offices and courts in the region, which are in charge of the effective processing of the corruption signals. During the discussion, representatives of the private sector and the civil society suggested that the countries from the region explore the possibility for increased use of disciplinary actions, such as fines and dismissals of public servants. On the one hand, these can prevent a corruption action before it happens, and on the other hand, the procedures are faster than in criminal prosecution.
Day 3 of the training was be dedicated to the role of the civil society as drivers of the EU transformation processes, and the importance of CSO networking. The CSOs and grassroots were able to hear best practices from practitioners, experienced in building CSO anticorruption coalitions and achieving policy impact. SELDI members and other partner CSO organisations also shared their methodologies and good practices, with a focus on the monitoring of public spending and public administration reforms, further inspiring CSOs and grassroots to engage in these areas. A specific focus was placed on the process of CSOs developing analytical content. The participants agreed that CSOs need to always be innovative and improve their methods of effectively communicating advocacy messages, including through infographics and videos, published on YouTube, Instagram, Facebook and other social media.
Day 1 presentations:
Presentation by Daniela Mineva, Research Fellow, Economic Program, Center for the Study of Democracy, SELDI Knowledge and Outreach (Adobe PDF, 1.8 MB)
Presentation by Dr. Alexander Gerganov, Senior Analyst, Center for the Study of Democracy, SELDI Knowledge and Outreach and Assistant Professor at the Institute for the Study of Societies and Knowledge (Bulgarian Academy of Sciences) (Adobe PDF, 1.8 MB)
Presentation by Igor Cocic, Grant Manager, Centers for Civic Initiatives (CCI) (Adobe PDF, 521 KB)
Presentation by Jasmina Ristovska, Project Coordinator, Macedonian Center for International Cooperation (Adobe PDF, 511 KB)
Presentations by SELDI’s grantees:
Presentation by Agon Hysaj, Democracy Plus, Kosovo* (Adobe PDF, 565 KB)
Presentation by Momir Dejanovic, Centar za humanu politiku, BiH (Adobe PDF, 690 KB)
Presentation by Ivana Stosic, Roma Center for Democracy, Serbia (Adobe PDF, 115 KB)
Presentation by Marinela Dervishi, CSR Communication, Albania (Adobe PDF, 2 MB)
Presentation by Jasmina Mihailovska, Studiorum, North Macedonia (Adobe PDF, 317 KB)
Presentation by Miloš Vukanović, CGE/CCO, Montenegro (Adobe PDF, 615 KB)
Day 2 presentations
Semir Mujkic, Deputy Editor, Balkan Investigative Reporting Network – BIRN, Bosnia and Herzegovina
Aleksandra Martinovic, Transparency International, BiH
Blerim Kelmendi, Anti-Corruption Agency, Kosovo*
Ksenija Mitrovic, Head of Unit for Education, Anti-Corruption Plans and Strategy in the Sector for Prevention and Integrity Strengthening, Serbian Anti-Corruption Agency
Evgjeni Bashari, High Inspectorate for Declaration and Control of Assets and Conflicts of Interest, Albania
Biljana Ivanovska, President of the Macedonian State Commission for Prevention of Corruption
Day 3 presentations
Viktorija Nesterovaite, Civil Society Team, UNODC
UNCAC meeting Outcome Statement on the role of CSOs in addressing corruption, 1 February 2019 in Belgrade, Serbia
Milos Djindjic, Programme Manager, European Policy Centre – CEP, Serbia
* This designation is without prejudice to positions on status, and is in line with UNSCR 1244/1999 and the ICJ Opinion on the Kosovo declaration of independence.